Hello dear
Welcome to Depot 25 Restaurant
Depot 25 Restaurant, located at 15 W Main St in Shortsville, NY, is a charming dining destination that combines excellent food with an inviting atmosphere steeped in history. Formerly a train depot, the restaurant features nostalgic train memorabilia. Customers rave about the diverse menu, including standout dishes like the fried calamari, Cuban sandwiches, and Seafood Fra Diavolo, which offer generous portions and flavorful experiences. With attentive service and a cozy ambiance, Depot 25 is perfect for gatherings, ensuring you feel right at home. Exceptional value and memorable culinary delights make Depot 25 a must-visit for anyone in the area.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
French Onion Soup
Escargot
Large House Salad
Romaine Salad
About
Depot 25 Restaurant
Welcome to Depot 25 Restaurant, a charming dining gem located at 15 W Main St, Shortsville, NY 14548. Nestled in a nostalgic setting that showcases an array of intriguing train memorabilia, this former train depot offers guests not just a meal, but a delightful experience steeped in history.
Depot 25 Restaurant shines with its welcoming ambience and attentive service. The establishment has made a mark on its patrons, as highlighted by returning customers like Nick Bodine, who fondly recalls family memories intertwined with this beloved locale. The cozy atmosphere sets the perfect stage for enjoying a diverse menu that tantalizes the palate.
Guests rave about the Friday fish fry, noted for its generous portions and delectable flavors. Diners have described it as a satisfying feast featuring a substantial piece of fish accompanied by comforting smashed potatoes and a refreshing coleslaw. The Cuban sandwich, praised for its robustness, is another highlight that sets this restaurant apart from others. Stacy Romaine aptly described her experience with it, calling the unique "fries" perfectly seasoned and irresistible.
Seafood lovers also delight in the Seafood Fra Diavlo, served with a choice of spicy marinara or creamy Alfredo sauce. This dish, brimming with clams, mussels, scallops, and shrimp, has left numerous diners in awe of its size and flavor, making it a must-try for first-time visitors.
For those seeking a more refined taste, the Caesar salad has garnered praise for its rich, creamy dressing; while pasta lovers might find a standout in the house specials, even if there's room for improvement in flavoring some sauces, as noted by Christina Premo.
However, it's important to acknowledge the mixed feedback regarding wait times and meals, as shared by Dave Burley. Customer satisfaction is paramount, and while many have enjoyed swift and friendly service from the dedicated staff, there have been isolated incidents of delays. Yet, patrons like Todd Moore have appreciated the hard work and commitment of the servers, particularly in busy periods.
Ultimately, Depot 25 Restaurant embodies a lovely fusion of warmth, history, and delightful cuisine. Its reasonable pricing and dedication to quality make it a visit worthy of any food lover in the area. The spirit of community and nostalgia is palpable, making every meal not just about food, but about connection. Bring your family and friends, and enjoy a seat in this treasured local eatery—you won't want to leave without trying the Italian lemon cream cake!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We hadn’t been here in years but 4 of us went for dinner this evening. Made reservations for 4 of us when they opened at 4pm, for 6pm, and they were pretty busy when we arrived. Got a comfy table in a corner and a friendly server, but we all missed her name as it was a little loud in there, or maybe just hard to hear for some reason. One of us got the Friday fish fry and it looked good and she reported it was delicious. Nice big hunk of fish, the smashed potatoes looked awesome, and a small cup of coleslaw. I got the Cuban sandwich with “fries” and oh boy was that good! You don’t see that in the menu too many places. And the little French fry things were very different but seasoned nicely and I ate them up quickly! Hubby and his dad both got the Seafood Fra Diavlo- dad with the spicy marinara as shown on the menu, and my husband requested his with Alfredo sauce instead. And they both RAVED! Huge plate of linguine and then I think they had like 6 clams, 10 mussels, 3 BIG scallops, some calamari tubes, 3ish shrimps and 3 teeny ! They were very happy and full. We also ordered appetizers - fried calamari which 3 of them shared and very plentiful (nobody liked the flavor of the pickled stuff that came with it, but the calamari itself was great I guess) and also cheesy garlic bread which there were 8 nice pieces of with sauce. Plus free fresh bread and whipped butter. The servers all were hustling as it was busy but we were happy with our service. And the prices were very reasonable for the quantity and quality of food we got. from the 4 of us and we’ll be back! ”
“ The service was amazing! Creamiest Caesar dressing ever! Loved the Italian lemon cream cake We both had pasta dishes-pasta was delicious but sauce is a little bland! We would definitely recommend this place! ”
“ Not a good dining experience. I ordered pork chops ,medium rare and a baked potatoe. We waited for over an hour for our food. My pork chops were well done and when they finally arrived. I was informed that they were out of baked potatoes. However, when i ordered my meal they had them. I will not be going back anytime soon. They did comp our drinks because of the long wait for our food. ”
“ Excellent food and great service. Both Jackie and Diane were great. We had a party of 7 and you could tell they were short staffed. These ladies worked well together and were non stop busy! Most importantly, they did not make us feel rushed... food was spot on. Lamb Chops, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Pork Chops and Steaks were all ordered and came out to the correct temps. Have to add that the lemonade was the best. ”
“ I have been going to the depot 25 restaurant for some time now. It's such a wonderful cozy atmosphere with all kinds of old train memorabilia. (It does just so happen to be an ol train depot) My mother is from Manchester and she has told me my father an her would go down to the depot for a drink back on the early 80's. They said the bar would be 2 deep and my grandfather was always there for a couple as it was his local hang out. For me this place is filled with rich history and it's always like a trip back in time. The food is lovely, the service is great and the prices are Very reasonable. ”
“ hats off to connie and her crew. my wife and i were there on saturday the 22nd. busy as could be they had a wedding party of 25 and another party of 16. service was awesome food was of course awesome. all the employees were working their tails off. nice job peeps!!!!!! thank you tim and darla ”
“ Went for my sister's birthday, 4 of us. The food was delicious but our service was very disappointing! Jackie started out good but once we has our salad she completely let us down. The final straw was she let us sit for 30 minutes for our check, I had to go ask a person clearing tablets for it. ”
“ This is a wonderful neighborhood restaurant! Our food was home cooked and delicious. The menu is varied and offered many tantalizing pastas. The chicken was tender, my haddock was well prepared and the service was friendly and attentive. The decor in the old rail station sports original woodwork, fascinating old locomotive photos and baseball memorabilia. You can tell by the clientele that everyone is a repeat customer. We will be too. ”